# Is coconut water better than a sports drink?

Source: https://www.healthnews24.co.za/answers/coconut-water-vs-sports-drink/
Publisher: Healthnews24 (South Africa's supplement answer desk)
Updated: 2026-10-27

> No. In one controlled study, coconut water rehydrated about as well as a sports drink and water after exercise in heat, but its extra potassium gave no added benefit. Coconut water is low in sodium, the main mineral lost in sweat, and has little carbohydrate for fuel. For long events, a sports drink is the better tool.

Key facts:
- A 2014 crossover study of 12 adults found coconut water rehydrated no better than a sports drink after exercise in 32 degrees Celsius heat; its extra potassium added no benefit.
- The sports drink retained 68.2% of fluid versus 51.3% for bottled water; coconut water did not differ significantly from either.
- Sweat sodium ranges roughly 10 to 90 mmol/L; coconut water is low in sodium and carbohydrate.
- Electrolyte sachets cost about R4.63 to R25 per serving in South Africa (October 2026).

## What did the research find?

A 2014 crossover study (Pérez Idárraga and Aragón-Vargas, Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and Metabolism) dehydrated 12 active adults by about 2.1% of body mass in a 32 degree Celsius chamber. On four days they drank 120% of their fluid loss as fresh coconut water, bottled water, a sports drink or a potassium-rich drink.

| Drink | Urine output over 3 h | Fluid retained |
|---|---|---|
| Bottled water | 894 ml | 51.3% |
| Sports drink | 605 ml | 68.2% |
| Potassium-rich drink | 599 ml | 65.9% |
| Fresh coconut water | 686 ml | 62.5% |

Coconut water did not differ statistically from the others, and none of the drinks produced a positive net fluid balance within three hours. The authors concluded that the extra potassium gave no additional rehydration benefit beyond a conventional sodium-containing sports drink. This is a small study of 12 people, so treat it as supportive rather than definitive.

## How do they differ?

- **Sodium:** sweat is mostly sodium, up to roughly 10 to 90 mmol/L between athletes. Coconut water is potassium-rich but low in sodium, so by itself it under-replaces what you lose in long, hot sessions.
- **Carbohydrate:** most sports drinks are designed to supply fuel as well as fluid. Coconut water has some natural sugar but far less carbohydrate than the 30 to 90 g/h used in long events.
- **Taste and tolerance:** coconut water scored higher for sweetness and all drinks were well tolerated. Some people find it easier to drink after a session.

We have not priced coconut water brands in South Africa, so no Rand comparison is given. For electrolyte products, see [how much electrolytes cost](/answers/how-much-do-electrolytes-cost-per-serving-south-africa/): sachets run about R4.63 to R25 per serving (October 2026).

## When does coconut water make sense?

- A light session under an hour, or recovery alongside a salty meal.
- When you want a lower-sugar, flavoured drink that is not a standard sports drink.
- As part of a snack after training, with something containing sodium and protein.

## When should you choose a sports drink instead?

- Events over 1 to 2 hours, especially in Durban or Lowveld heat.
- Training when you need carbohydrate fuel as well as fluid.
- Heavy or salty sweaters: see [do I need electrolytes or just water](/answers/do-i-need-electrolytes-or-just-water/).

Marketing claims that coconut water is "nature's sports drink" go beyond the evidence. Neither is essential: for sessions under about an hour, water is enough.

## Who needs to be careful?

Coconut water is rich in potassium. People with kidney disease, or taking ACE inhibitors, potassium-sparing diuretics or some blood pressure medication, should ask their doctor before using it regularly. People with diabetes should count the sugar. Pregnant women should check with their doctor if they are on blood-pressure medicines, and children need only water and food for normal sport.

Compare ready-made options on our [best electrolytes in South Africa](/best/best-electrolytes-south-africa/) page.

## Products mentioned

| Product | Size | Price (source, date) | Servings | R per serving | Sweeteners |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Biogen Electrolyte (3 x 10 sachets, citrus) | 3 x 10 sachets | R139–R155 (Dis-Chem (electrolytes group), 2026-10) | 30 | R5.17 | Not published |
| Lifestyle Electrolyte Fizzy (10 tablets) | 10 effervescent tablets | R48–R53 (Dis-Chem (electrolyte drinks page), 2026-10) | 10 | R5.30 | Not published |
| Biogen Pure Energy sports electrolyte drink (500 g, mango orange) | 500 g | R99–R115 (Biogen (own shop), 2026-10) | 28 | R4.11 | Sucralose |
| REVIVE Raw Daily Electrolytes, unflavoured (30 sachets) | 30 sachets | R319–R399 (Faithful to Nature, 2026-10) | 30 | R13.30 | None (unsweetened, unflavoured) |

## Sources

- [Pérez Idárraga & Aragón-Vargas 2014, Post-exercise rehydration: potassium-rich drinks vs water and a sports drink (Appl Physiol Nutr Metab)](https://www.kerwa.ucr.ac.cr/handle/10669/11062)
- [Baker 2017, Sweating rate and sweat sodium concentration in athletes (Sports Med)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28332116/)
- [Hew-Butler et al. 2015, Third International Exercise-Associated Hyponatremia Consensus Statement (BJSM 49:1432)](https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/49/22/1432)